Starmer's Llama Drama: When Identity Politics and Health Policy Collide

By Martin Foskett

​In a move that has left many in bewilderment, Prime Minister Keir Starmer's recent appointment to the Department of Health has ignited a firestorm of controversy, blending the absurdity of identity politics with the gravitas of public health.

​If you thought British politics had exhausted its supply of eyebrow-raising moments, think again. The latest instalment of Westminster weirdness features only Prime Minister Keir Starmer, a newly appointed Health Minister, and—wait for it—a llama.

It all started with the unceremonious sacking of Andrew Gwynne, whose questionable WhatsApp messages led to his swift exit from the Department of Health. There is nothing too shocking there—politicians texting themselves into oblivion is practically a national pastime. But then came the replacement: Ashley Dalton, the Labour MP for West Lancashire. And this is where the drama begins.

As it turns out, Dalton has a rather unconventional take on identity politics. In past comments that have resurfaced, she suggested that people should be free to identify as anything they choose—including a llama. That's right—a llama—presumably one with full access to public healthcare.

Dalton also championed the idea of abolishing gender-specific bathrooms, arguing against "sexually differentiated" facilities in favour of a more fluid approach. In the grand scheme of progressive politics, this might be par for the course. But in the world of public health policy—where practical considerations tend to outweigh theoretical ones—such views have been met with, shall we say, a mix of bemusement and outright disbelief.

Conservative MP Richard Holden wasted no time in responding. "The idea that someone who thinks people can identify as llamas is fit to be a health minister is beyond belief," he declared, likely while clutching his morning cup of tea with slightly more force than necessary.

It's the kind of political appointment that forces you to check the calendar to ensure it's not April 1st. But no, this is real. It has raised the interesting question: where exactly is the line between inclusivity and absurdity?

When handled with care, identity politics can be a force for good by acknowledging diverse experiences and ensuring fairness in policymaking. But when it veers into the realm of the surreal, it risks alienating the people it seeks to support. 

Regardless of political affiliation, most Brits likely agree that a functioning Department of Health should focus on NHS waiting lists, medical staff shortages, and, oh yes, making sure hospitals have enough beds—not debating whether one's species is a personal choice.

For his part, Starmer has remained relatively quiet on the llama controversy, perhaps hoping it will fade into the background of Britain's already chaotic news cycle. But as the debate continues to swirl, one thing is clear: politics in 2025 remains as unpredictable as ever.

#Starmer #LlamaDrama #IdentityPolitics #UKPolitics #DepartmentOfHealth